FAQ
Shopping near Hershey, Harrisburg & Lebanon
Where can I buy quality secondhand clothes near Hershey, PA?
My Second Story Consignment is based in Palmyra, PA, about 10 minutes from Hershey. Shop 1,500+ pre-loved pieces for women, men, kids and babies online at mysecondstory.co and choose free porch pickup in Palmyra, or get free shipping on orders over $30.
Is there a consignment shop in Palmyra, PA?
Yes. My Second Story Consignment is a family-run consignment shop in Palmyra serving Hershey, Hummelstown, Annville, Lebanon and Harrisburg. We don't have a walk-in storefront yet; everything is online with free local porch pickup. More about our shop.
How does porch pickup work?
Choose Pickup at checkout. We'll email you when your order is ready along with the pickup details for our porch in Palmyra, PA.
What we sell
Where can I buy used Spanx jeans?
We carry pre-loved Spanx flare, skinny and straight-leg pull-on jeans and pants, including plus and tall sizes, well below retail: Spanx resale.
Do you sell baby and toddler clothing lots?
Yes. Our baby and toddler clothing lots bundle bodysuits, sleepers and outfits from Carter's, Cat & Jack and more, newborn to 5T, for one low price. Every lot lists exactly what is included.
Do you have secondhand plus size clothing?
Yes, in sizes 1X to 4X from Spanx, Maurices, Lane Bryant, Torrid and more: plus size clothing. XL and XXL are under Shop by Size.
What brands do you carry?
Popular brands include Old Navy, Banana Republic, LOFT, Gap, American Eagle, Nike, Carter's, LuLaRoe, Maurices and Under Armour.
Are your clothes new or used?
Mostly gently used clothing from local closets, plus some new with tags pieces. Every listing shows its condition and real photos of the actual item.
What do your condition grades mean?
New: never worn, often with tags. Excellent: barely worn, no visible flaws. Good: normal light wear, any flaws are shown. Fair: noticeable wear, priced to match. See the condition guide.
Orders, shipping & returns
Do you offer free shipping?
US orders of $30 or more ship free; orders under $30 ship for a flat $8. Express shipping is $15. International orders ship by USPS at the calculated rate.
What is your return policy?
Every item is one of a kind and sold as described. If an item arrives significantly not as described, contact us within 3 days of delivery and we'll make it right. All other sales are final. Full policy.
What payment methods do you accept?
All major credit and debit cards, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Shop Pay, PayPal and gift cards. Shop Pay Installments lets you pay over time on orders over $35.
Do you have discounts?
Join our email list for 20% off your first order, and buy 3 or more items to save 15% automatically. Check Clearance and $10 & Under.
Consigning
Can I consign my clothes with you?
Yes. We photograph, list and sell your quality pieces, and you get paid. Learn how consigning works, and consignors can log in at portal.mysecondstory.co.
How do I contact you?
Email info@mysecondstory.co or use our contact page.