Consignment & Thrift Shop near Hershey, Harrisburg & Lebanon
My Second Story Consignment is a family-run consignment shop based in Palmyra, Pennsylvania, right between Hershey and Lebanon. We sell quality pre-loved clothing for women, men, kids and babies from local closets, at thrift prices, and every piece is checked by hand, photographed and condition-graded.
Shop online, pick up in Palmyra
Our whole shop is online at mysecondstory.co with 1,500+ one-of-a-kind pieces and new arrivals every week. Shoppers in Palmyra, Hershey, Hummelstown, Annville, Campbelltown, Lebanon and Harrisburg can choose free porch pickup in Palmyra at checkout. Everyone else gets free shipping on orders over $30.
What we carry
- Women: jeans, sweaters and cardigans, dresses, leggings and activewear and plus sizes 1X to 4X
- Kids and baby: baby and toddler clothing lots, Carter's, girls and boys
- Men: shirts, pants and outerwear
- Brands shoppers love: Old Navy, Banana Republic, LOFT, Gap, American Eagle, Nike, Under Armour, Spanx, LuLaRoe and Maurices
- New with tags, $10 and under and clearance
How we grade condition
Every listing shows a condition (New, Excellent, Good or Fair) and real photos of the actual item. See our condition guide for what each grade means.
Consign with us
Have clothes your family has outgrown? We photograph, list and sell your quality pieces, and you get paid. Learn how consigning works.
Questions?
Email info@mysecondstory.co or use our contact page. Recycle. Reuse. ReLove.