Skip to content

Join our email list and get 20% off your first order

Free shipping over $30 · Free porch pickup in Palmyra

Home
Women
Men
Kids
Shop by Size
Accessories
Clearance
Candles
Gift Cards
Consignor Login
Contact

USD

Search

Country/Region

No results found

Women's Tops

Women's Bottoms

Women's Dresses

Maternity

Women's Outerwear

Women's Swimwear

Women's Loungewear

Women's Shoes

Men's Tops

Men's Bottoms

Men's Outerwear

Men's Swimwear

Men's Loungewear

Men's Shoes

Girls

Boys

Toddler & Baby

Shoes

Women's & Men's

Plus

Men's Pants (Waist)

Baby & Toddler

Kids

All Clearance

$5 & Under

$10 & Under

Consignor Login

Search

Country/Region

No results found

Account

Your cart is empty

Have an account? Log in to check out faster.

Continue shopping

✓ 1,800+ pieces sold on eBay, Poshmark & Depop ✓ Every item photographed & condition graded ✓ Free porch pickup in Palmyra, PA

$5 & Under

Skip to results list

Active filters:

290 items

Sort

Sort Date, new to old

Featured

Most relevant

Best selling

Alphabetically, A-Z

Alphabetically, Z-A

Price, low to high

Price, high to low

Date, old to new

Date, new to old

Column grid

Column grid

Filter

Active filters:

Sort

Sort Date, new to old

Featured

Most relevant

Best selling

Alphabetically, A-Z

Alphabetically, Z-A

Price, low to high

Price, high to low

Date, old to new

Date, new to old

Old Navy Luxe Womens Large Burgundy Floral V-Neck Puff Short Sleeve Top Shirt

Sale

Old Navy Luxe Womens Large Burgundy Floral V-Neck Puff Short Sleeve Top Shirt

Old Navy Luxe Womens Large Burgundy Floral V-Neck Puff Short Sleeve Top Shirt

$3.00

Sale price $3.00 Regular price $10.00
Emory Park Womens Mauve Pink Ribbed Tiered Babydoll Flutter Sleeve Top Size M

Sale

Emory Park Womens Mauve Pink Ribbed Tiered Babydoll Flutter Sleeve Top Size M

Emory Park Womens Mauve Pink Ribbed Tiered Babydoll Flutter Sleeve Top Size M

$3.00

Sale price $3.00 Regular price $10.00

Shop local in Palmyra, PA

Choose Pickup at checkout for porch pickup and skip shipping. Questions? Email info@mysecondstory.co.

My Second Story

Consign with us
About
Contact
Return policy

Join our email list

Get 20% off your first order and be the first to see new pieces each week.

Email

© 2026 My Second Story, Powered by Shopify

Privacy policy
Refund policy
Shipping policy
Terms of service
Contact information

Search

Search

Products

Aerie Leopard Print Tie Front One Piece Swimsuit Womens S Spaghetti Strap

Aerie Leopard Print Tie Front One Piece Swimsuit Womens S Spaghetti Strap

$7.00

Regular price $27.00 Sale price $7.00
Aerie M White Denim Shorts Womens Distressed Cut Off Boho Casual

Aerie M White Denim Shorts Womens Distressed Cut Off Boho Casual

$9.00

Regular price $12.00 Sale price $9.00
Aerie Womens M Blue Raglan Sweatshirt Casual Cozy Athleisure Pullover

Aerie Womens M Blue Raglan Sweatshirt Casual Cozy Athleisure Pullover

$13.00

Regular price $26.00 Sale price $13.00
Aerie Womens M Olive Green Waffle Knit Pullover Sweater Oversized Casual Cozy

Aerie Womens M Olive Green Waffle Knit Pullover Sweater Oversized Casual Cozy

$15.00

Regular price $30.00 Sale price $15.00